QUOTE(moif)
Perhaps its because I'm not American that I get so many Americans telling me where their families come from? Maybe Julian will read this tomorrow though and say otherwise.
No, I get that too. Though it seems that the Americans who research this the most are those whose ancestors arrived in America after the Revolution.
Perhaps it's a problem with the records from that far back, but it seems quite rare for Americans from colonial stock, most of whom were of English, Welsh or Scot
tish origins (
kmsouthern, if you ever visit Scotland, don't refer to anything but the alcoholic drink as "Scotch" unless you
like being shouted at), to have traced their ancestry back to Britain.
It's much more common among the descendants of later immigrants to America to have a memory of which town or village in "the old country" they were from. I'm not sure why; I'd guess that originally it was socially quite useful to hang on to one's cultural identity in a possibly transient and hostile society, and that later on it the additional glamour and exoticism of
not being a standard-issue white of British descent with a surname like Jones or Smith had its own allure.
I think I've pondered this before here, in wondering why St Patrick's Day is such a big celebration in the US, and St David's Day is ignored, even though there are not significantly more Irish surnames than Welsh ones in the Boston or New York phone directories (I checked. Pathetic, I know.).
Of course, I'm probably colouring this opinion with my own experience (as a standard issue white of British descent with a surname like Jones or Smith) - we Brits are generally less interested in finding out our heritage. Probably because we grow up knowing we are still living in it, I think we take it for granted much more than most Americans would* - there's not so much to be nostalgic about.
A good example of this I read about recently was that genetic tests on a pre-historic skeleton found in limestone caves in Cheddar Gorge, Somerset, revealed that one of the dead man's descendents still lived in Cheddar village. As far as anyone could tell, the family (at least, this branch of it) had never lived more than a mile or so from the cave in the
9,000 intervening years.
*or do - I am still astonished at the different treatment given to the Gettysburg National Memorial and the comparable historical battlefields of Britain. At Gettysburg, you get a guided tour and visitor centre. At Bosworth Field, you get unsignposted farmland and, if you're unlucky, and angry farmer telling you to get off his land. *sigh*
Wikipaedia entry for Cheddar CavesCheddar Man's DescendentWhere do you come from?I'm at Welsh at least three generations back, mostly in Cardiff, where I was born. Before that, I think one set of great-grandparents were a Spanish Jew who married a local Welsh woman (Cardiff was a port for centuries, so this is not that unusual) and produced my maternal grandmother; one were Welsh-speaking hill-farmers from near Caerphilly (my maternal grandfather's parents). On my dad's side, I think both sets of my great grandparents moved to Cardiff from England (I'm not sure where) to take jobs in the burgeoning 19th century coal and steel trades there.
How has your family's history affected your own life?Other than an awareness (and pride) at my Welshness (which may have as much to do with having been born and raised there) and my work ethic (which isn't really unique to my family), not very much that I'm aware of.
Do you think its important to know where your family is from?Yes, up to a point. Genealogy has always been one of those things I would like to research at some point. My maternal aunt has done some research and pulled together a family tree of my maternal grandmother, in particular the Spanish angle, going back about 200 years. She hasn't done anything on the Welsh side (her father's). Again, I suspect that this is to do with the glamour of the exotic (with a healthy dose of the good old British class system). One day, I'd like to do the same for the rest of my family.
But family trees alone are just diagrams, without some biographical detail. What did they do for a living? Why did they move from town X to town Y? Did their fortunes change over time, and in what direction?
The BBC made a fascinating series along these lines earlier this year ("Who do you think you are?"), in which celebrities dug into their family history. The most interesting (and moving) editions went back no further than three or four generations, but dug into family secrets - "why was mother committed to an asylum?", "who was the father of my illegitimate grandmother?", "what happened to my grandfather's first wife?" and so on.
Perhaps it's my own ignorance of my own family that makes me think this would a be more interesting route than just trying to build a family tree as far back as possible - my grandparents and father all died before I was 25, so I never really got to know them while they were alive. Got to know them as people, rather than as family roles, I mean.