Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Bourse
America's Debate > Archive > Assorted Issues Archive > [A] Economy and Business
Google
Trouble
I recently ran across an article which grabbed my interest. The article written by Mr. Krassimir Petrov describes that much of the heightened tension between the west and Iran can be attributed to this monetary event.
My questions are:

Do you feel this new reserve currency posses a threat to the dollar?
-If no, please provide reasons.
-If yes, how will the Fed respond?

Do you feel this event has any bearing on the adminstration's posture towards Iran?
Google
skeeterses
Do you feel this new reserve currency posses a threat to the dollar?
Yes it is, because of the fact that the Euro is widely enough to be a viable alternative to the dollar. If Iran did open its oil bourse, I don't think that would be enough to make the dollar collapse. It's pretty hard to predict what the Fed Reserve is going to do. In fact, I have heard that in March, the Fed is going to stop publishing information on the M-3 supply.

Do you feel this event has any bearing on the adminstration's posture towards Iran?
I don't think so. Europe seems to be getting angry at Iran as well. So in this case, it really may be about the WMDs and not the oil or the dollar issue.
Also, there were UN sanctions on Iraq prior to 2003, essentially crippling trade with Iraq. So Saddam Hussein dumping his dollars is probably a mute point.
Trouble
QUOTE
Do you feel this new reserve currency posses a threat to the dollar?
Yes it is, because of the fact that the Euro is widely enough to be a viable alternative to the dollar. If Iran did open its oil bourse, I don't think that would be enough to make the dollar collapse. It's pretty hard to predict what the Fed Reserve is going to do. In fact, I have heard that in March, the Fed is going to stop publishing information on the M-3 supply.


I have heard that as well. My guess is any impact the Bourse may have will be masked from the M3 reporting. This will be hard to quantify but I expect the Bourse to gain momentum further in the year.

QUOTE
Do you feel this event has any bearing on the adminstration's posture towards Iran?
I don't think so. Europe seems to be getting angry at Iran as well. So in this case, it really may be about the WMDs and not the oil or the dollar issue.
Also, there were UN sanctions on Iraq prior to 2003, essentially crippling trade with Iraq. So Saddam Hussein dumping his dollars is probably a mute point.


For detailed breakdowns on the effects of the Security Council and pre-9/11 events in Iraq, I found Scott Taylor's "Spinning on the Axis of Evil" book insightful. I found the book very helpful in describing the abysmal condition in Iraq that forced Saddam to escalate the situation with the euro. Taylor describes a woefully inefficient body that was never intended to fix the situation. It was merely a stop gap measure. The council was very successful fiscally. I expect a desire to cut and paste the situation elsewhere.

I think any country that is receptive to the bourse will be chasticed heavily and may even end up on the 'axis list'.
Amlord
Where is the sense of perspective from the alarmists out there?

The United States has a 11.75 trillion dollar GDP. Iran exports $68 billion in oil.

That is a small, small amount relative to the whole (the US is not Iran's main trade partner, either).

Even Paul Krugman says that this is must ado about nothing (back when he was an liberal economist and not a liberal ideologue).

QUOTE
Well, then, you may say, surely the international role of the dollar forces people out there to hold dollars for transaction purposes. Yes, but not so you'd notice. When Daewoo repays a dollar loan from Sanwa, it writes a check on its account with some international bank. True, that bank itself surely maintains an account in New York, backed in part by non-interest-bearing reserves held at the Fed. So the U.S. does in effect get a zero-interest loan out of the dollar's international role--but it probably amounts to only a few billion dollars, small change for an $8 trillion economy.
 

Where the U.S. does get a significant free ride is from the willingness of foreigners to accept our currency--actual bills. Foreigners hold more than $200 billion of American money. Guess what kind of business requires payments of large sums in cash, by people unconstrained by official restrictions on possession of foreign exchange? That's right: the dollar is the world's premier medium of illicit exchange. Every year the U.S. ships foreigners $15 billion in cash (about 0.2% of GDP), and gets real goods and services in return. Better not ask what kind.
 

So the threat to the U.S. from the rise of the euro is this: five years from now, when wise guys in Vladivostok make offers you can't refuse, the payoffs may be in 100- euro notes instead of $100 bills. The loss of such business might cost the U.S. economy as much as 0.1% of GDP. Somehow, I think we can live with that.


Here's another take:
QUOTE
I don't know much about what Iran is planning (nor does a Google search yield much trustworthy information), but this fear is based on faulty economics.  As a first-order approximation, it doesn't much matter whether Iran prices its oil in terms of dollars, Euros, or some other currency.  At the beginning of each day, investors (including the OPEC nations) are holding their preferred bundle of currency positions.  You might need to hold or receive Euros for a moment to make a transaction, but moving from the dollar to the Euro, or vice versa, can be done easily.

Two qualifiers: First, some investors will hold more Euros to begin with.  They don't know their periodic demands for oil, and they don't want to be bothered paying a bid-ask spread and calling a broker when the time comes to pay for oil.  But this is likely to be a small effect.  Major market players generally do not regard these conversion costs as a decisive investment factor.  Bid-ask spreads in the dollar-Euro market are small, and if the dollar fell by a large amount it would be worth buying dollars cheaply and bearing subsequent transactions costs of a later reconversion at a superior rate.

Second, the dollar's status as reserve currency depends in part on perceptions.  If pricing oil in terms of Euros altered those perceptions, the value of the dollar could fall.  But most of all those perceptions depend on relative economic performance.  An Iranian "oil bourse" is likely to be. in psychological terms, a non-event, especially if Iran continues down its path as international pariah.  Note that Saddam's efforts to price oil in terms of Euros did not end up as a big deal.


Do you feel this new reserve currency poses a threat to the dollar?

Not in the least, especially considering the lackluster performance of the European GDP.

Do you feel this event has any bearing on the adminstration's posture towards Iran?

I don't think so. Why should a non-event influence our decisions of national security?
Google
This is a simplified version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.