I don’t know
BD. A music therapist spoke to a professional development meeting I attended in the 90s. She thought that music worked for mentally retarded people because it involves a different part of the brain than cognition. I don’t know if she was right or wrong.
I like all kinds of music – things that I got from my grandmother – Bob Wills, Gene Autry, Tommy Dorsey and Glenn Miller. She even had Count Basie’s
Open the Door Richard on a 78.
My mother loved Perry Como and my father liked Nat "King" Cole.
I still like what my grandmother and parents like, but I’ve expanded – the blues and RB of the 40s and early 50s the mid 50s rockers, the protest stuff of the 60s, the British Invasion, the groups like the Eagles, The Supremes, The Temptations, Australia’s AC/DC obscure big bands like Jimmy Lunceford and on and on.
I don’t deeply analyze any of it – I analyze enough in other areas – I just enjoy.I recently ordered a CD of New Orleans based
Lloyd Price’s 1952-53 Specialty label recordings. “Lawdy Miss Clawdy” “sends me” as Sam Cooke told us. The original 1952 version (a hit on the RB, but not the pop charts) featured Fats Domino on piano backed Dave Barthlowmew’s band. It had a slow to medium tempo that the listener just sort of naturally got into. Elvis Presley did a cover on “Lawdy Miss Clawdy.” His version was good, but lacked the power of Dominio’s piano and Barthlomew’s band. Price recut “Lawdy Miss Claude” for another label years later. He upped the tempo to the point that it sounded more like they were racing to a fire than playing music. I liked Price’s original version better than Presley’s, but Presley’s better than Price’s recut.
I don’t know if this is what you wanted, but it keeps your somewhat interesting thread on the playing field.
Again, I analyze things musical a little, but not much. I just enjoy.