QUOTE(Lesly @ Aug 20 2007, 03:35 PM)

According to
this article, Rotenberg centers must get probate court approval to shock students.
Is restraining/isolating/shocking mentally and/or emotionally troubled students an acceptable disciplinary tool? If yes, why can't parents do the same?This seems just downright sick to me. Who in the world thinks this is ok?
I realize kids can be troublesome, but a backpack to carry around that shocks them? Wow. That's absurd. Maybe a restraint here and there (surely not all the time) and a few drugs to help them cope... and even that seems like a last resort to me.
This quote says it all:
QUOTE
Despite spending more than three years at this behavior-modification facility, Rob still has problems controlling his behavior. In 2005, he was arrested for attempted assault and sent to jail. (This year he was arrested again, for drugs and assault.) Being locked up has given him plenty of time to reflect on his childhood, and he has gained a new perspective on the Rotenberg Center. "It's worse than jail," he told me. "That place is the worst place on earth."
I guess this sums it up. Years of shock treatment- he's still messed up. Not good news for whatever state Rob lives in.
Then you have this paragraph:
QUOTE
The Rotenberg Center has a policy of not giving psychiatric drugs to students—no Depakote, Paxil, Risperdal, Ritalin, or Seroquel. It's a policy that appeals to Louisa and many other parents. At Andrew's last school, she says, "he had so many medicines in him he'd take a two-hour nap in the morning, he'd take a two-hour nap in the afternoon. They'd have him in bed at eight o'clock at night. He was sleeping his life away." These days, Louisa says she is no longer afraid when her son comes home to visit. "[For him] to have an electrode on and to receive a ged is to me a much more favorable way of dealing with this," she says. "He's not sending people to the hospital."
I dunno. This is where it gets sticky. Do some kids need shock therapy? Is it a whole lot different than other forms of discipline? (i.e. spanking?)
However- the rest of the article paints a pretty grim picture. I can't imagine what terrible parents think this is ok?
Some people probably need aggressive treatment. But is this is the answer for most of the people there? Wow.