Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Palestine and Israel
America's Debate > Archive > Policy Debate Archive > [A] Foreign Policy
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
Google
Rev_DelFuego
QUOTE(Dontreadonme @ Nov 19 2003, 08:48 PM)
QUOTE
Like the racist conference in South Africa a week before Sept 11.

I guess that racist would be a good term for the UN World Conference Against Racism, considering their treatment of Israel in the proposed language of the UN declaration.

QUOTE
[The World Conference recognizes with deep concern the increase of racist practices of Zionism, anti-Semitism in various parts of the world, as well as the emergence of racial and violent movements based on racism and discriminatory ideas, in particular, the Zionist movement which is based on racial superiority;]

Link

Tell me doesn't a race that considor themselves "gods choosen people" seem a little racist to you? And since this race is "gods choosen people" the should be able to displace anyone they want?
Google
DaytonRocker
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 19 2003, 03:50 PM)
So who decides "overboard." How about Rafah last month. 1000 people homeless and dozens killed. The US government didn't even look twice and it barely made the news.

I love how Palestinian sympathizers leave out the other half of the story. The IDF had started "Operation Root Control" that takes out the smuggling tunnels. These tunnels were/are being used to transport Stinger missiles in from Egypt. STINGERS for Pete's sake. You know, these things that could take down helicopters and civilian airliners???

So the Pals start shooting back to defend the tunnels and get killed. And what happens? Somebody here acts like the IDF targeted innocents - as usual. Israel made and is making perfectly reasonable responses to the terrorists acts against it. Cutting off the weapons flow saves innocent lives on BOTH sides.

You should be applauding the efforts in Rafiah if you were truly interested in saving the lives of innocents.
Dontreadonme
QUOTE
Tell me doesn't a race that considor themselves "gods choosen people" seem a little racist to you?

No, it doesn't. Many people and races have considered themselves anointed, or chosen, by their deity. It's not something I subscribe to, but it certainly doesn't meet my standard of racism. Israel conducting itself in it's own self interest does not constitute anything other than survival.
Rev_DelFuego
QUOTE(DaytonRocker @ Nov 19 2003, 09:12 PM)
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 19 2003, 03:50 PM)
So who decides "overboard." How about Rafah last month. 1000 people homeless and dozens killed. The US government didn't even look twice and it barely made the news.

I love how Palestinian sympathizers leave out the other half of the story. The IDF had started "Operation Root Control" that takes out the smuggling tunnels. These tunnels were/are being used to transport Stinger missiles in from Egypt. STINGERS for Pete's sake. You know, these things that could take down helicopters and civilian airliners???

So the Pals start shooting back to defend the tunnels and get killed. And what happens? Somebody here acts like the IDF targeted innocents - as usual. Israel made and is making perfectly reasonable responses to the terrorists acts against it. Cutting off the weapons flow saves innocent lives on BOTH sides.

You should be applauding the efforts in Rafiah if you were truly interested in saving the lives of innocents.

Yes all 1000 homeless families were Pal. sympathizers. Tell me when was the last time you saw stinger missles used in Pal. to shoot down civilian aircraft? And your telling me one of the most advanced armies had to destroy countless homes to destroy these tunnels?
QUOTE
No, it doesn't. Many people and races have considered themselves anointed, or chosen, by their deity. It's not something I subscribe to, but it certainly doesn't meet my standard of racism. Israel conducting itself in it's own self interest does not constitute anything other than survival.

Well I consider anything that deems me inferior at birth with no proof racists. So what if other races considor themselves anointed, it doesn't make them right. Thats like Hitler was ok for saying blues eyes and blond hair was a dominat race. And as far as survival goes they are doing more than survivng. Sharon has establish over 50 illegal settlements since he took office. Usually when someone is trying to survive they are losing ground not taking it.
GoAmerica
QUOTE(DaytonRocker @ Nov 19 2003, 03:12 PM)
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 19 2003, 03:50 PM)
So who decides "overboard." How about Rafah last month. 1000 people homeless and dozens killed. The US government didn't even look twice and it barely made the news.

I love how Palestinian sympathizers leave out the other half of the story. The IDF had started "Operation Root Control" that takes out the smuggling tunnels. These tunnels were/are being used to transport Stinger missiles in from Egypt. STINGERS for Pete's sake. You know, these things that could take down helicopters and civilian airliners???

Yes. I believe something like that was attempted last year exactly (give or take a few days) in Africa(?)

QUOTE
So the Pals start shooting back to defend the tunnels and get killed. And what happens? Somebody here acts like the IDF targeted innocents - as usual. Israel made and is making perfectly reasonable responses to the terrorists acts against it. Cutting off the weapons flow saves innocent lives on BOTH sides.


That and when ever Israel has a bad day & they decide to knock off a Hamas leader who is driving down a street, they accidently kill a civilan, the whole world (except us) goes nuclear. Everyone thinks Israel does this for kicks and they call them terrorists, meanwhile, Arafat won't let his PM's tell the PA to go take out Hamas militants.
moif
DTM

QUOTE
No, it doesn't. Many people and races have considered themselves anointed, or chosen, by their deity. It's not something I subscribe to, but it certainly doesn't meet my standard of racism. Israel conducting itself in it's own self interest does not constitute anything other than survival.


Care to give some examples of who you have in mind? blink.gif
Rev_DelFuego
Well I just thought I should bring up a few articles that irks me.
Houston Chronicle
This article is very misleading. The headline is "Sharon wants to ease tension with Palestinians" but says "Additionally, I don't rule out unilateral steps" while the arabs who initiated the conference get noo credit at all. here's another version. The BBC


The BBC
Can you find anything like this in a US news paper? They never show any of the Israeli misdeeds, but I bet when a terrorist strikes tomorrow it will be on the front page CNN, Fox, and the other usual suspects.
Ted
Both sides need to come to the table to negotiate. Israel must stop the building of settlements on occupied territory and the Palestinians need to control Hammas. Then there is a chance for peace. Other than that the Palestinians have little chance to have a homeland.
Bob
Could someone please fill me in on what exactly the greenline is? Thanks
GoAmerica
QUOTE(Ted @ Nov 21 2003, 03:44 PM)
Both sides need to come to the table to negotiate.  Israel must stop the building of settlements on occupied territory and the Palestinians need to control Hamas.

Stopping the settlements: Maybe

Controlling Hamas: HA HA HA laugh.gif

The settlments pop up for everyone taken down. Controlling Hamas is like trying to stop an inferno with spit. Hamas is just too powerful to be controlled
Google
lucius
QUOTE(Dontreadonme @ Nov 19 2003, 09:15 PM)
Israel conducting itself in it's own self interest does not constitute anything other than survival.

The racist National Party government of South Africa took plenty of actions in its own interest to try to ensure the survival of a white ruled country. The fact it was fighting for its survival did not make it any less racist.

Here are three policies of Israel which are clearly racist:

Immigration: an Arab whose parents were born in what is now Israel is blocked from entering the country, whereas Jews who have no recent family links to Israel/Palestine can settle there.

Mobility within Israel/Palestine: Jews living in the West Bank (i.e. settlers) can move freely throughout Israel and the West Bank. Arabs living in the West Bank are subject to severe restrictions on their movements.

Demolitions of Arab homes: the Jerusalem municipal authorities discriminate against Arabs in Jerusalem by demolishing their homes for supposed building violations. The municipality's own data shows that there are more than five times as many building violations in Jewish West Jerusalem as in Arab East Jerusalem and yet in 2001 five times as many homes were destroyed in East Jerusalem as in West Jerusalem - see link: http://www.rebuildinghomes.org/wl/pj-beit-...ves/000122.html
Robin_Scotland
For me, condeming both sides for their equally outrageous behaviour rather than taking action against one side is the only way to go. This conflict is bad enough, but it is being fuelled by American support for Israel. Yes, I want to see an end to conflict, and do not condone terrorism. At present, the world (and in particular the Muslim world) looks at the situation and sees America condoning violence. No point trying to justify it, that is how it is. And for me, its morally wrong. In that case, if I think America is doing something that goes against my morals, should I be supporting military intervention against America? Afterall, that is the lesson we learn from America.

We intervene in conflicts and support who we do because its our moral obligation. Ive heard that over and over. Moral obligation? Whose morals? Not mine. So basically what is being said is one group of morals - dictatoral decisions. I coulnd't possibly support any group or nation that is acting in such a manner (Israel I mean). Terrorist attacks are no excuse in my book. Violence is violence.
Billy Jean
QUOTE
Sharon Vows Arab State if Attacks Stop

JERUSALEM - The Palestinians are assured of a state if they halt attacks on Israelis and dismantle armed groups, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon (news - web sites) said Monday. But he also tried to ease fears among his right-wing backers that he will dismantle settlements as a concession to peace.

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...lestinians_1541

If this doesn't start the Mid East peace process back down the right path, nothing will. And if Hammas and the PLO attack now, then it's obvious that Palestine doesn't want peace. ermm.gif
Rev_DelFuego
Look at the link I provided 3 days ago. The "terrorist groups" have been talking about peace for a few days now.
Billy Jean
Actually, these are KNOWN terrorist groups, no quotation marks needed , thankyou. shifty.gif

http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/rpt/fto/2001/5258.htm
GoAmerica
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 24 2003, 12:58 PM)
Look at the link I provided 3 days ago. The "terrorist groups" have been talking about peace for a few days now.

Yes...but how long will it last? How do we know it is not a reason to stall so these terrorist groups can re-build themselves? During their little offensive a couple weeks ago ago, Israel killed a lot of Hamas leaders. How do we know that Hamas is not just trying to get more leaders to start the whole thing? Or are they waiting for Hanakuah or Thanksgiving to start up again?
Rev_DelFuego
QUOTE(GoAmerica @ Nov 24 2003, 10:20 PM)
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 24 2003, 12:58 PM)
Look at the link I provided 3 days ago. The "terrorist groups" have been talking about peace for a few days now.

Yes...but how long will it last? How do we know it is not a reason to stall so these terrorist groups can re-build themselves? During their little offensive a couple weeks ago ago, Israel killed a lot of Hamas leaders. How do we know that Hamas is not just trying to get more leaders to start the whole thing? Or are they waiting for Hanakuah or Thanksgiving to start up again?

How do we know that Israel won't continue to build settlements in W.Bank and Gaza? How do we know they won't shut down an economic center?
Rev_DelFuego
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 24 2003, 10:44 PM)
QUOTE(GoAmerica @ Nov 24 2003, 10:20 PM)
QUOTE(Rev_DelFuego @ Nov 24 2003, 12:58 PM)
Look at the link I provided 3 days ago. The "terrorist groups" have been talking about peace for a few days now.

Yes...but how long will it last? How do we know it is not a reason to stall so these terrorist groups can re-build themselves? During their little offensive a couple weeks ago ago, Israel killed a lot of Hamas leaders. How do we know that Hamas is not just trying to get more leaders to start the whole thing? Or are they waiting for Hanakuah or Thanksgiving to start up again?

How do we know that Israel won't continue to build settlements in W.Bank and Gaza? How do we know they won't shut down an economic center?

Well, I hate to tell you I told you so but:

QUOTE
Palestinian officials plan to secure a pledge from militant groups next week to halt all attacks against Israel, which they will present along with a demand for full implementation of the U.S.-backed "road map" peace plan, the top Palestinian negotiator said Tuesday.


QUOTE
Jewish settlers are proposing their own plan, which calls for dismantling the Palestinian Authority and incorporating the West Bank into Israel. The plan, which has little chance of success, demonstrated the many pressures on Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.


CLOSED - due to age & length. Feel free to start a new debate.
This is a simplified version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.