Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Liberals in Academia
America's Debate > Archive > Social Issues Archive > [A] Education
Google
ElliotFladen
Question for debate/discussion -
Why do you think there are so many liberals in academia?

Liberals in Academia. Liberals Conforming. Coincidence?
Three takes
1) Robert Brandon - Academics are smart, and tend to be liberal. Liberals tend to be smarter
2) Glenn Reynolds - Most Academics are Lazy
3) Arnold Kling - Liberals tend not to like responsibility, and academics tend not to need responsibility, so liberals end up as academics

My take? Where is this "liberals are smarter" argument coming from? Yes, there a lot of dumb conservatives out there. However, of the truly intelligent people that I have met in my life, very few have been liberal. Almost all have ended up being libertarian. How do I reconcile this with the fact that almost all of my law professors are liberal? Well, almost all my econ professors have been libertarian, so like I said, the most intelligent people that I have met in my life have tended to be libertarian tongue.gif

Seriously why are there so many liberals in academia? Obviously I don't believe that liberals are smarter. Nor do I buy the argument that liberals don't like to take on responsibility, mainly because it conflicts with my personal experience, and there is always a drive to change the world that many of those on the left possess (tough to view going to africa with the peace corp and working for an obscure tribal village as not wanting to take responsibility).

I think the best explanation is that the Academy rewards cleverness so long as it conforms to accepted norms. Further, social pressures of the university causes more students who tend to be susceptible to groupthink/believing acceptable things to become liberal than conservative/libertarian. Liberals, having a greater concentration of individuals who have a history of conformity, succeed better in a field that demands it, leading to the disparity.
Google
Mrs. Pigpen
We had a similar thread about this subject here. It is old, so I will close that one and we can continue the discussion on this one. flowers.gif
Jaime
CLOSED.

Upon further review, this thread appears to be a reprint of your personal blog. Do not blog here and add a debate question. That is considered SPAM and strikes will be issued.

If you would like to debate us, please do so, but do not use us to advertise your blog.
Google
This is a simplified version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.