Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: New Intelligence Director
America's Debate > Archive > Policy Debate Archive > [A] Domestic Policy
Google
turnea
John Negroponte sure is a popular guy in the Bush Administration...
QUOTE
President Bush today named John D. Negroponte as the director of national intelligence, a new position that will oversee the country's 15 intelligence agencies and exercise broad control over a multi-billion dollar intelligence budget.[...]"John brings a unique set of skills to these challenges," Mr. Bush said in a ceremony at the White House.

Mr. Negroponte said he was honored to be nominated by the President and called the job "the most challenging assignment I have undertaken in more than 40 years of government service."

Mr. Negroponte, 65, has been serving as the United States ambassador to Iraq since last summer, a tenure Mr. Bush called an "incalculable advantage for an intelligence chief." Mr. Negroponte had re-established that position shortly before the transfer of sovereignty to an interim Iraqi government in late June.

Before that, Mr. Negroponte had served as United States ambassador to the United Nations.[...]
At least three potential nominees approached by the White House have turned the job down, officials have said.

Lt. General Michael Hayden of the Air Force will serve as Mr. Negroponte's deputy director, Mr. Bush said. Mr. Hayden, who was said to have been on the White House's short list of nominees for the head position, is the director of the National Security Agency and the chief of the Central Security Service.

Bush Names Iraq Envoy as Nation's 1st Intelligence Chief

Questions

Is John Negroponte the right choice for the job of intelligence director?
Why or why not?

Do you expect intelligence performance to improve due to this appointment?
Google
phobosmoon3
I don't know if Negroponte will be the best man for the job for the biggest intelligence reform in the past 50 years. Its such a huge job, it is hard to tell who will be able to handle it best. What I do hope is accomplished is that the turf fighting to get more budget money comes to end... and more efficient spending by a way for discerning what projects get the money and what projects don't. Hopeful that will create the ultimate purpose of the new intelligence tsar, better intelligence... better safety for the american people. A good article to read concerning this matter is on the Economist website:

http://www.economist.com/agenda/displaySto...tory_id=3685274

P.S.

I think hints of what kind of intel tsar Negroponte can be, are in his wheelings and dealings in Latin America.
Wertz
Is John Negroponte the right choice for the job of intelligence director?
No.
Why or why not?
While "set a thief to catch a thief" sounds good in theory, I don't think that someone who is merely good at organizing covert, illegal operations and covering up atrocities is necessarily qualified to gather or collate intelligence.

Do you expect intelligence performance to improve due to this appointment?
That depends on what you mean. Had Negroponte been an intelligence czar for the past three years, we would doubtless never have heard about Abu Ghraib or any of the abuses at Gitmo - or, at least, those who broke the stories would be dead. So, if keeping information from the American people by any means necessary is an "improvement", sure, he'll be great. He's certainly an insider with the intelligence community, but I rather suspect that his skills will best serve things like setting up domestic internment camps for US citizens - and maybe murdering a few nuns.

Frankly, I cannot think of a worse human being to put in charge of anything - except maybe Henry Kissinger.
Antny
Just thought I'd share some of FAIR's findings about Mr. Negroponte's record that didn't hit the media...

QUOTE
From 1981 to 1985, Negroponte was the U.S. ambassador to Honduras, a country that was being used as a training and staging ground for the CIA-created and -backed Contra armies, who relied on a terrorist strategy of targeting civilians. Those years saw a massive increase in U.S. military aid to Honduras, and Negroponte was a key player in organizing training for the Contras and procuring weapons for the armies that the United States was building in order to topple the socialist Nicaraguan government (Extra!, 9-10/01).

Negroponte's ambassadorship was marked by another human rights scandal: the Honduran army's Battalion 316, which operated as a death squad that tortured, killed or disappeared "subversive" Hondurans-- and at least one U.S. citizen, Catholic priest James Carney. Despite regular reporting of such crimes in the Honduran press, the human rights reports of Negroponte's embassy consistently failed to raise these issues. Critics contend that this was no accident: If such crimes had been acknowledged, U.S. aid to the country's military would have come under scrutiny, which could have jeopardized the Contra operations.


http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=2452

The rest of the FAIR article looks at the accuracy of the media in discussing Negroponte's past. Interesting read.

I don't think Negroponte is the right guy. His shady past, known to the world, will raise the level of skepticism and hatred of the US, as if it needs any help.

I have no idea what to expect from "intelligence" as far as performance goes. Is there any integrity left? Apparently, the latest piece of technology will allow "us" to tap into all sorts of new eavesdropping capability. That could be interesting...

QUOTE
The Washington Post reports on a new US Submarine capable of tapping sub-ocean laser communications trunk lines all around the globe. The Wash. Post states: According to intelligence experts, it can tap undersea cables and eavesdrop on the communications passing through them. The military has just opened the door to trade, business, and economic espionage on both our allies and enemies.


http://poliwatch.org/

It's gotta make you think...
Google
This is a simplified version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.